skip to Main Content

Going beyond implemention with non-state and subnational climate action

Egypt is hosting this year’s UN Climate Change Conference in Sharm El Sheikh. The slogan of this year’s conference is ‘Together for Implementation’. However, by merely implementing existing pledges under the Paris Agreement, governments would certainly spell the death of the goal to limit global warming to 1.5°C. 


Photo by: Joseph Eid

Governments must go beyond mere implementation and raise ambition. Last year’s UN Climate Change Conference in Glasgow saw the mobilisation of an unprecedented number of businesses, cities and other non-state and subnational actors. They voluntarily pledged to climate neutrality (Race to Zero); to leverage financing (Glasgow Financial Action for Net Zero, GFANZ); and to build resilience among communities at risk (Race to Resilience). There is an enormous opportunity for governments to harness the ambition of these actors to lower emissions, leverage financing, and build adaptive capacities. And yet, only a handful of governments (5 percent) have referred to voluntary non-state and subnational action in their NDCs (UNFCCC 2022). 

An important reason why governments may be slow to recognise the potential of the pledges by non-state and subnational actors, is the lack of reliable data and analyses that non-state and subnational actors are delivering on their promises.

An important step in providing authoritative data and analysis is the release of “Global Climate Action 2022: How have international initiatives delivered, and what more is possible?”, by NewClimate Institute, IDOS, and Radboud University. The report addresses non-state and subnational climate initiatives which collaborate across borders. Despite their large and growing number, these initiatives have performed worse since 2018, especially in adaptation and climate resilience building. More than half of major climate initiatives launched at UN climate conferences and summits since 2014 do not deliver necessary behavioural changes or improvements in environmental indicators (including the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions). Moreover, most actors participating in these initiatives are from Europe and North America and a disproportionate share of activities taking place in the Global North, raising the question whether transnational climate cooperation is exacerbating gaps between developed and developing countries.

COP27 will be an important moment to increase the credibility of non-state and subnational climate initiatives. For instance, the High-Level Expert Group on the Net-Zero Emissions Commitments of Non-State Entities has presented its report with practical recommendations and criteria to improve integrity, transparency and accountability of non-state actor’s net-zero pledges. Our report provides evidence for the need of robust and well-designed non-state and subnational initiatives, which we hope will incentivize governments and the UN Climate secretariat to look beyond promises and stimulate transparency and accountability among the initiatives they recognize.



NewClimate Institute, German Institute of Development and Sustainability (IDOS), Radboud University. 2022. Global Climate Action 2022: How have international initiatives delivered, and what more is possible? Research report prepared by the team of: Takeshi Kuramochi, Sander Chan, Sybrig Smit, Andrew Deneault, Natalie Pelekh. 


Download the report



This piece was written by Sander Chan (Radboud University/German Institute of Development and Sustainability) and Andrew Deneault (German Institute of Development and Sustainability – IDOS) who are at COP27 this week.

More articles

2023 RadboudNews
2023 Radboud Conference: Q&A Sessions with the International Project Office

The Call for Papers is now available for the 2023 Radboud Conference on Earth System Governance!…

Marine Social Sciences: For the Ocean We Want
A manifesto for ocean social science that emerged from an online workshop conducted at the Leibniz Centre for Tropical marine Research (ZMT) on Oct 4th 2022.
2022 TorontoNews
Looking back at the Toronto Conference
Amid the changing autumn leaves, scholars from across the world met up in Toronto for the Earth System Governance Conference 2022, which took place from the 20th to the 24th of October. The world continues to rapidly change, as different challenges and crises arise and are dealt with on different governance levels. The challenge for this research community is to create knowledge on how to ensure that throughout all these changes, the sustainability transition continues to advance in a just way.